Does Robb Stark die twice?

Chia sẻ
Nhúng
  • Xuất bản 03 Th02, 2018
  • Does Robb Stark die twice at the Red Wedding? How are the Stark children connected to their direwolves? How do wargs live second lives in their wolves?
    Subscribe: bit.ly/ASXSubscribe
    Facebook: bit.ly/ASXFacebook
    Twitter: bit.ly/ASXTwitter
    Patreon: bit.ly/ASXPatreon
    Buy A Game of Thrones Book 1: amzn.to/292Jmwy
    Buy ASOIAF Books 1-5: amzn.to/2970vVu
    Buy Game of Thrones Season 7 Blu-ray: amzn.to/2C6Smjp
    Created with Adobe After Effects, a Shure SM7B microphone, and a Focusrite Scarlett audio interface: www.amazon.com/shop/altshiftx
    Images and video from Game of Thrones are the property of their creators, used here under fair use.
    Art by Ertaç Altınöz used with permission: ertacaltinoz.deviantart.com/
    References/further reading:
    asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php?/topic/87919-did-robb-stark-warg-into-grey-wind-as-he-died/
    www.reddit.com/r/asoiaf/comments/3dtwaw/spoilers_all_grey_wind/
    nobodysuspectsthebutterfly.tumblr.com/post/71269920977/why-was-robbs-last-words-greywind
    gendrie.tumblr.com/post/162055283915/it-is-curious-to-find-the-wolf-as-a-character-in
    Special thanks to Patrons Reverend Xandria, Cameron Weiss, @Vineyarddawg, Maryam Essa, Neel Chopdekar, Michael Appell, Jason Rattray, Ryan Steele, Eric Louis-Dreyfus, Thee Stevie Franchise, Alex Kirkendall, Triangle Wine Company, Harry, Fred Petty, LightCraft Miniature Studios, Matthew Elisha Williams, Jake Burling, Chris Amolsch, Chris Cole, Cregg Riley, Bobby Eales, Patrick Lorang Skoglund, Hank Lero, Zach Gordon, Gina Penney, Valentin Degen, DscoDan, Jesse Deal, DylanGeekozoid, Dervis Yeniavci, Nazeef Mashroor.

NHẬN XÉT • 1 391

  • Alt Shift X
    Alt Shift X  8 tháng trước +409

    From GRRM's script for GOT S4E02: "Robb sits drenched in blood amidst the carnage of the Red Wedding, surrounded by the dead. His dead face slowly transforms into Grey Wind’s wolfish features."
    Source: www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2018/12/game-of-thrones-george-rr-martin-last-script-the-lion-and-the-rose

    • Hollow Shell
      Hollow Shell 7 tháng trước +7

      Hydro Moe because the show has to simplify everything. In the books, it’s clearly explained that a warg is a specific type of skin changer that has a relationship with a wolf. The show of course thinks very little of the intelligence of its fan base so they simplify everything so people don’t get confused

    • Hydro Moe
      Hydro Moe 7 tháng trước +9

      @Brynden Rivers no Warg is the general term for any skin walker. The Wildling with the Eagle was called a Warg repeatedly.

    • Geno Porreca
      Geno Porreca 7 tháng trước +2

      Great video. Could listen to you talk all day

    • Brynden Rivers
      Brynden Rivers 7 tháng trước +7

      It's specifically stated in the world of Ice and Fire that Warg specifically and only refers to a skin changer that has a relationship with a wolf and is not just another generic term for any skin changer

    • Veganazi Animista
      Veganazi Animista 7 tháng trước +2

      Hey, do you have a video about the theory that Jaine Westerling is carrying Robb's baby?

  • anon X
    anon X 16 ngày trước

    when this dude died I realized anyone can die in this fucking show

  • Todd Howard
    Todd Howard 20 ngày trước

    Lol idiot what are you talking about? Robb never dies, stupid

  • Cheren Tee
    Cheren Tee 21 ngày trước

    I for one glad this oathbreaker suffered the same fate twice..

  • Skyler Star S.
    Skyler Star S. 25 ngày trước +1

    Hey just letting you know that “travesty” isn’t the proper word. A travesty is a bad misrepresentation of something.

  • Tom Fisher
    Tom Fisher 27 ngày trước

    Love this, one note, the warg ability is in the body, and once you leave your body, you can only return to your body or die. As Varamyr could not leave his wild body after his mans body died.

  • John doe
    John doe Tháng trước

    Dire wolves are like wolves, only dire.

  • Tiranus
    Tiranus Tháng trước

    Sekiro: Wolfs Die Twice

  • nem kevin
    nem kevin Tháng trước

    wait grey wind died before robb :/

  • Nicolas Teissier
    Nicolas Teissier Tháng trước

    STOP SPOILING THE SHOW ON THUMBNAILS THINK ABOUT THOSE WHO HASNT SEEN THE SCENE, BASTARDS

  • Marshal Saini
    Marshal Saini Tháng trước

    Animals were harmed during the production of this movie. Lmao

  • His Dudeness
    His Dudeness Tháng trước

    Literally Sekiro

  • DARTH VADER
    DARTH VADER Tháng trước

    If they asked what happened here, Tell them winter came for house frey

  • Hallveig Fróðadóttir
    Hallveig Fróðadóttir Tháng trước +2

    Robbs last words are “Mother..”

    • Lord Costayne
      Lord Costayne 5 ngày trước

      "Jeyne?" Robb grabbed the edge of the table and forced himself to stand. "Mother," he said, "Grey Wind . . ."

  • GodHimself
    GodHimself Tháng trước +2

    Is this video a troll? Regular people can't warg into animals...

  • Eran Boazy
    Eran Boazy Tháng trước +1

    Don't know what about you, But I'm team Ghost all the way

  • The Ill Mannered Gentlemen
    The Ill Mannered Gentlemen Tháng trước +1

    FFS MARTIN WHERES THE NEXT BOOK?!

  • John Toth
    John Toth Tháng trước +1

    This video would be better if your voice wasnt boring as shit.

  • Justin Throneberry
    Justin Throneberry Tháng trước +1

    Damn just damn.

  • Iggy Marr
    Iggy Marr Tháng trước

    I just read the Red Wedding and Arya does not watch Grey Wind, die. In her chapter she watches people get killed and hears a wolf from a far and immediately gets hit on the head by The Hound... Did I miss something?

  • DPTavares
    DPTavares Tháng trước

    Spoil the books much?

  • Bruul619
    Bruul619 Tháng trước

    Rob dies after dire wolf...

  • Sravan Karuturi
    Sravan Karuturi Tháng trước

    I am pretty sure varamyr says/thinks that once you warg out of your body and your body is killed, you cannot warg out anymore. And so he has to chose one of the wolves. And decides on the one eyed leader instead of the younger male wolf. So, Robb cannot warg out of grey wind after he dies.

  • Mom
    Mom Tháng trước

    Seeing such a big character killed and mutilated really got to me for some reason

  • Vaibhav Tripathi
    Vaibhav Tripathi 2 tháng trước

    Robb's last word is mother not greywind.

    • Lord Costayne
      Lord Costayne 5 ngày trước

      "Jeyne?" Robb grabbed the edge of the table and forced himself to stand. "Mother," he said, "Grey Wind . . ."

  • Benjamino
    Benjamino 2 tháng trước

    Can they just do a true to book Tv show that doesn’t waste everyone’s time??

  • Constant Respawn
    Constant Respawn 2 tháng trước

    WHYNDID ROBB DIE

  • Roy
    Roy 2 tháng trước +1

    His final word was ‘mother’ and he died after grey wind...

    • Roy
      Roy 2 tháng trước

      Alt Shift X did you mention that in the video? That you were referencing the book not the film (you are literally showing the film)

    • Alt Shift X
      Alt Shift X  2 tháng trước +1

      The books are different to the show!

  • Ivan Ungui
    Ivan Ungui 2 tháng trước +1

    robb stark's last word was "mother" not "grey wind" ulol ahahah

    • Ivan Ungui
      Ivan Ungui Tháng trước

      @Lord Costayne gogogo

    • Lord Costayne
      Lord Costayne 2 tháng trước

      "Jeyne?" Robb grabbed the edge of the table and forced himself to stand. "Mother," he said, "Grey Wind . . ."

  • Emilio Rossi
    Emilio Rossi 2 tháng trước

    It was Catelyn and Rob's fault for making such stupid decisions.

  • Keith Crisman
    Keith Crisman 2 tháng trước

    Sorry just saw this video. better late than never. is it possible that Robb is living a third life in Sir Westerly his brother in-law and replacement for Jon.. how he acted after GreyWind died is at best. and he could still be alive

  • Epic Sauce
    Epic Sauce 2 tháng trước

    The North remembers

  • D3lt4
    D3lt4 2 tháng trước +2

    Game of thrones:
    Robb dies twice.

  • Harry Tippins
    Harry Tippins 2 tháng trước

    Can we all agree Rickon has the worst name for his direwolf

  • luvprue1
    luvprue1 2 tháng trước

    Rob is killed, than his direwolf is killed. So he could have died twice.

  • Boddje
    Boddje 2 tháng trước

    Wasnt his last Word «mother»

    • Boddje
      Boddje Tháng trước

      Lord Costayne i was talking about The series version

    • Lord Costayne
      Lord Costayne 2 tháng trước

      "Jeyne?" Robb grabbed the edge of the table and forced himself to stand. "Mother," he said, "Grey Wind . . ."

  • Caliosaaa
    Caliosaaa 2 tháng trước +1

    So all the stark children had warg powers!? Was this said in the books?

    • chitownboyz
      chitownboyz 3 giờ trước

      Martin said it they all do but so far we only see bran, Jon, Arya warg with their wolf.

  • SpikedPuddingStudios
    SpikedPuddingStudios 2 tháng trước

    That catelyn quote is really really heartbreaking. Something about it just made me cry. I didn’t even cry during the show Red Wedding 😂

  • Stefan StickRun
    Stefan StickRun 2 tháng trước

    Robb betrayed Walder Frey, thats why he died, Catlyn and Robb swore to the gods that he will marry Walders daughter, after some time he married another woman, that woman is the reason why the whole pack of soldiers died with their leaders!

  • Valorius Zephyr
    Valorius Zephyr 2 tháng trước

    A man disagrees

  • Logan L
    Logan L 2 tháng trước

    Ghost🍞🍞

  • Logan L
    Logan L 2 tháng trước

    Craziest episode on tv

  • Gotham Knight
    Gotham Knight 2 tháng trước

    This is such a clickbait video. I suppose the purpose of this video is to theorize that Robb warged into his direwolf, Greywind just before he died? So the conclusion is Robb never died twice. He only does once when he theoretically warged into Greywind. If he was already legally dead he would have lost all brain function and wouldn't have been able to warg.
    This guy is basically telling us a lie from the damn thumbnail. Also, this channel never faces the terrible ending the show had cuz he wants to be "positive" channel about game of thrones. However, it is an OBJECTIVE fact that season 8 was a poorly written farce with inconsistent characters, and poor attempts at character shifts. Alt+Shift+X should be ashamed of himself.

  • Maryam Zaheri
    Maryam Zaheri 2 tháng trước

    Nahhhh! What is dead may never die

  • PersonalTea338
    PersonalTea338 2 tháng trước +1

    i doubt robb got into raynald because only the most powerful and experienced wargs can enter humans. Even vyamir wasn't able to successfully take over that girl

  • OP Malfit
    OP Malfit 2 tháng trước

    Yes.
    In Game of thrones and in Game of bones

  • DannyRogers1993
    DannyRogers1993 2 tháng trước +1

    I remember I bitched about them not showing this happen in the show way back when I used to post on the forums and no one thought this was an actual thing. Like yes, it's implied pretty heavily that all wargs warg into their animals at the point of death and every Stark child has warging abilities...

  • CrazzyJokerr
    CrazzyJokerr 2 tháng trước +2

    I have a Alaskan Malamute, she looks like the wolves in the show and follows me everywhere, when I stop when we are walking to check my phone or sth else, she sits next to me immediately. I never trained her to do that, she did this since I got her as a puppy.
    Maybe I'm a Stark ?!

    • CrazzyJokerr
      CrazzyJokerr Tháng trước

      @Noxillius listen u genius, normaly u need to teach such behavior to a dog, especially malamutes who do what they want. I meet with the other dog owners of her brothers and sisters twice a year and she is the only one who stays with me unless I tell her to go and run. Her siblings barely even do what the owners tell em. Most of the times they continue playing instead of following orders. These people even asked me for my secret and I told them I have no clue why she does that. And dogs are not intelligent as u suggest they are very sensitive and this behavior isn't intelligent, it's just extremely uncommon especially for this race.

    • Noxillius
      Noxillius Tháng trước

      Oh my god?! Intelligent animals are intelligent?!@# Who would've thought!!

  • HartSickle
    HartSickle 2 tháng trước

    No, Shadows die twice.

  • Andrew Kane
    Andrew Kane 2 tháng trước

    But his wolf dies before he does (in the show anyway). They kill the wolf, and then he finally gets stabbed one last time and dies.

  • ojay Z
    ojay Z 2 tháng trước

    Summary is Robb is warg, so he died in his body and then grey wind

  • Thomas Kelly
    Thomas Kelly 2 tháng trước

    JON ISNT EVEN A FUCKING STARK U PIECE OF SHIT

  • Thomas Kelly
    Thomas Kelly 2 tháng trước +1

    The other Stark’s can’t become their wolves besides bran, 1:50

  • AM Channel
    AM Channel 2 tháng trước +15

    Title:Rob stark dies twice
    Me:...wut

  • Jiri Sojka
    Jiri Sojka 2 tháng trước

    Imagine the family meeting:
    Rob: I died twice and warged into human.
    Bran: I see everything past and future.
    Catelyn: I died and come back as zombie.
    Jon: I died. I was living in my pet's body and then came back to fight ice monsters.
    Rickon: I rode unicorns.
    Arya: I am no one who can change faces.
    Sansa: Whaaaat?

  • Ben Rich
    Ben Rich 2 tháng trước

    I honestly hope that 10 years from now when both of the final books are published we get another, more faithful interpretation of the Game of Thrones story

  • NanoDash
    NanoDash 2 tháng trước

    You only die twice

  • The Dank Ages
    The Dank Ages 2 tháng trước

    Starkiro: Roberts die twice

  • Boken ka gaming
    Boken ka gaming 2 tháng trước

    so shit is in the show Robb's last word in the show was mother and Jon's last word was Olly

  • Stoneryoda 937
    Stoneryoda 937 2 tháng trước

    Shit dude skin changers second life GreyWind

  • Allyson Fountain
    Allyson Fountain 2 tháng trước

    FUCK YOU

  • Ultimate Hope
    Ultimate Hope 2 tháng trước

    If Robb Stark died twice, would he be a shadow?

  • i think i'm a meanie
    i think i'm a meanie 2 tháng trước +33

    The Starks are so vulnerable to dying that Robb managed to die twice?

  • Crispy Mormon
    Crispy Mormon 2 tháng trước

    Robb Stark reaped what he sew. He got what he deserved, he was arrogant and stupid. He killed his men and his family through his actions, never once did he act like a king, he acted like a petty child who broke his word. He was no king.

  • Lvnae
    Lvnae 2 tháng trước +2

    The stitching of Grey Wind's head onto Robb's corpse is a mockery of the helmet Robb wears in the books, which is shaped like a wolf's head. Great video though.

  • Pytorite
    Pytorite 2 tháng trước

    Idk why u go into so much detail we all know it all

  • drog Rel
    drog Rel 2 tháng trước +4

    Bro the show should be an anime it would do everything justice especially the dire wolves ugh maybe one day

  • Logan Silke
    Logan Silke 2 tháng trước

    Now that GoT has ended, I feel like we missed out on the whole direwolf symbolism in the show. Only Bran ever worged into his direwolf, and as far as we can tell neither Grey Wind nor Ghost played a role in the death of Robb and Jon. Even Robb's last words are changed from "Grey Wind" to "Mother", which makes sense considering the story arc between Robb and Catelyn atleast in the show. There were only a few moments where the wolves were important, and those were mostly story driving or subtle hints, like when Bran first discovers his worging abilities and when Jon leaves Ghost at Winterfell in the final season, symbolizing Jon leaving his Stark roots behind and embracing duty to his queen(we all know how that ended up :P). I need to go and read the books now but I don't want to wait for the last two or three to come out lol

  • Zantrop64
    Zantrop64 2 tháng trước

    S H A G G Y D O G

  • Cross OveR
    Cross OveR 2 tháng trước

    0:48 Peekaboo Ar-see-ya.

  • london giles
    london giles 2 tháng trước

    sekiro: rob dies twice

  • Dominik Nöhring
    Dominik Nöhring 2 tháng trước +2

    Just a question:
    Did they beheaded Robb as well or did they just put the direwolves head over his?

  • Nathaniel Clark
    Nathaniel Clark 2 tháng trước

    Keeping Grey Wind near, keeping Roose Bolton near & never trusting a Greyjoy was some solid advice from Catelyn that Robb ignored. If he'd listened he might have lived.

  • C C
    C C 2 tháng trước

    What is dead may never die.

  • Regicide
    Regicide 2 tháng trước +16

    Sekiro: Robb dies twice

    • whodatboy
      whodatboy 2 tháng trước

      same thought haha

  • Shawn Simonis
    Shawn Simonis 2 tháng trước

    Still going to watch the video but hopefully it's yes, The King Who Lost the North was a total idiot and caused his own demise

  • aboomination
    aboomination 2 tháng trước +2

    If only Walder knew...he could've made Rob his own version of Reek.

  • Daggerman105 -
    Daggerman105 - 2 tháng trước

    People don’t seem to realise direwolfes were real animals. . .

  • Xedilian
    Xedilian 2 tháng trước

    This entire video can be awnsered with 1 word.

    No

  • Roslina Tamold
    Roslina Tamold 2 tháng trước

    So dumb to leave your most loyal guard locked up.

  • ClareBear
    ClareBear 2 tháng trước +4

    "The Red Wedding was one of the most tragic events in book or TV history - here, let's explore how it could be even more tragic." Thanks!

  • Ubysta44
    Ubysta44 2 tháng trước

    0:22 bruh

  • JoshySparklez
    JoshySparklez 2 tháng trước

    Only bran is a warg no other stark is

  • The Tgomes
    The Tgomes 3 tháng trước

    The Red Wedding was probably the best adaptation of the book we ever will see, the emotion and surprise it gave us is incredible.

  • Neo Crusader
    Neo Crusader 3 tháng trước

    No

  • Imreadyreadygogo
    Imreadyreadygogo 3 tháng trước

    Did you make a video explaining why Robb Stark was killed? I’m searching but can’t find it.

  • Prabhat Singh
    Prabhat Singh 3 tháng trước +4

    No shadow's die twice .
    Get it ?

  • TalhaTheOptimist
    TalhaTheOptimist 3 tháng trước

    *NO*

  • Pronte
    Pronte 3 tháng trước

    Robb Sekiro, I guess that's the rumored GRRM - FromSoftware project

  • Asian xQc
    Asian xQc 3 tháng trước +1

    Sekiro Rob Stark dies twice

  • Matt Darat
    Matt Darat 3 tháng trước

    Dude could you have a more monotone and boring voice?? Hahah wow

  • Colin Clayton
    Colin Clayton 3 tháng trước

    Complete bullshit that Robb didn't get any POV chapters.

  • Sam Whalen
    Sam Whalen 3 tháng trước +1

    The OG Sekiro

  • Zeemanhuismerk
    Zeemanhuismerk 3 tháng trước +4

    Yes cuz the actor played Sekiro

  • Rob G
    Rob G 3 tháng trước

    Morrron bookjonnnns rezzarection

  • Julien Alonso
    Julien Alonso 3 tháng trước

    VARAMYR LIVED IN HIS RAVEN NOT A WOLF

  • Blue/Two Paint/Hands
    Blue/Two Paint/Hands 3 tháng trước

    3:10 Jesus and Judas in the bottom right for some reason...

  • Zaid Ali
    Zaid Ali 3 tháng trước +1

    GoT: Robb dies twice

  • Berra Saral
    Berra Saral 3 tháng trước

    Sigh* if only